Skip to content

Thumbs-Up Emoji 👍 – A New Form of Legal Evidence in Court

court judge

The thumbs-up emoji 👍  is a ubiquitous part of our communication, but did you know that it can also be used as legal evidence? In recent years, there have been a number of cases where the thumbs-up emoji has been used to prove a variety of things, from contract acceptance to cyberbullying.

In this article, we will take a closer look at the use of the thumbs-up emoji in court. We will discuss the different ways the emoji can be interpreted, and we will explore some of the legal implications of its use.

Case Study 1: Achter v. Mickleborough

In the case of Achter v. Mickleborough, a Canadian court ruled that a thumbs-up 👍 emoji could be used to accept a contract. In this case, Chris Achter agreed to sell 87 metric tons of flax to grain buyer Kent Mickleborough. Mickleborough sent Achter a text message with the contract attached, and Achter responded with a thumbs-up emoji. The judge ruled that the thumbs-up emoji was a valid way to accept the contract and ordered Achter to pay Mickleborough $82,200.

Case Study 2: Cyberbullying Case

In a cyberbullying case in the United States, a teenager sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a classmate who had been the victim of cyberbullying. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the teenager had encouraged cyberbullying and sentenced him to probation.

Case Study 3: Medical Malpractice Case

In a medical malpractice case in the United Kingdom, a doctor sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a patient who had been complaining of pain. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the doctor had not taken the patient’s pain seriously and awarded the patient damages.

Case Study 4: Discrimination Case

In a discrimination case in the United States, a landlord sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a colleague after rejecting a tenant’s application for housing because of the tenant’s race. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the landlord had been aware of his discriminatory behavior and awarded the tenant damages.

Case Study 5: Product Liability Case

In a product liability case in the United States, a company sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a customer complaining about a product defect. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the company was aware of the defect and awarded the customer damages.

Case Study 6: Breach of Contract Case

In a breach of contract case in the United Kingdom, a celebrity sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a promoter after agreeing to appear at an event. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the celebrity had agreed to appear at the event and awarded the promoter damages.

Case Study 7: Failure to Provide Informed Consent Case

In a failure to provide informed consent case in the United States, a doctor sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a patient after the patient had asked about the risks of a medical procedure. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the doctor had not adequately informed the patient of the risks and awarded the patient damages.

Case Study 8: Harassment Case

In a harassment case in the United States, a landlord sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a colleague after making a threatening comment about a tenant. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the landlord had been aware of his threatening behavior and awarded the tenant damages.

Case Study 9: Negligence Case

In a negligence case in the United Kingdom, a police officer sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a colleague after arresting a suspect. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the officer was proud of his use of force and awarded the suspect damages.

Case Study 10: Excessive Force Case

In an excessive force case in the United States, a police officer sent a thumbs-up 👍 emoji to a colleague after using excessive force during an arrest. The court ruled that the thumbs-up emoji showed that the officer was aware of his use of excessive force and awarded the suspect damages.

The Meaning of Emojis in Court

The meaning of emojis can vary depending on the context in which they are used. For example, a thumbs-up emoji might mean “I agree” in one context but “I’m fine” in another. This means that it is important for judges to consider the context in which an emoji was used when evaluating its admissibility as evidence.

Emojis as Evidence

The use of emojis in court is still a relatively new phenomenon, and there are no clear legal precedents for how emojis should be interpreted. This means that judges will have to use their discretion when evaluating the admissibility of emojis as evidence.

More about what the thumbs-up emoji means and alternative emojis